Miami Beach 411
Like what you see? Let's talk about how
we can help your vacation --> Contact Us
  • Homepage
  • Plan Your Trip
  • Travel Forum
  • News & Events
  • Maps
  • Transportation
  • Tours
  • Hotels
  • Travel Tips
  • Reader's Reviews
  • News Archives
  • Need help? Call us! - 1-305-754-2206

Nature Girl: Carl Hiaasen Goes Native

July 28, 2008 By Matt Meltzer in  | 3 Comments


For those of you who follow Carl Hiaasen and his writing, you know that a few years ago his books started going from standard South Florida sleaze-crime-with-humor plots to South Florida sleaze crime- with-humor-and-an-underlying-environmental-message plots. Hiaasen is an unabashed advocate for the preservation of natural Florida, a cause that he champions not only in his weekly column for the Miami Herald, but also now in his books. “Nature Girl,” as the title might imply, is as much a story about a bunch of mixed up crazy people stuck in the 10,000 Islands as it is about the Everglades and its natural beauty.

Of course, Hiaasen being Hiaasen it is not exactly “River of Grass” with a zany subplot. It is a humorous and engaging, fast paced story that, surprisingly, actually makes you want to go out and spend some time in the middle of a swamp.


The story follows the format of many of Hiaasen’s books, where a collection of characters, none of whom are wholly sympathetic and many of whom are complete sleazes, end up converging in one place. And bedlam erupts. But unlike some of his previous works, the focal point of the story is not a crime or some sort of government corruption, but rather a harebrained plot by a borderline mentally-ill Everglades trailer-dwelling single mom to get revenge on dinnertime telemarketers.



The story begins as a half-breed Seminole named Sammy Tigertail (who may or may not, we discover, have a relation to the namesake of the street in Coconut Grove) buries a drunken tourist who accidentally dies on one of his airboat rides in the middle of the Everglades. Though he is disposing of the corpse to avoid any police repercussions, Sammy (formerly Chad McQueen of West Broward whose white father died and whose stepmother dropped him off on the doorstep of his Seminole mother) actually becomes the anti-hero of the book and and interesting symbol of what the tribe has become.


The book makes many a mention of the proud warriors of the Seminole tribe, who Sammy tries - unsuccessfully as most Hiaasen characters do - to emulate. But he is, after all, half white, and as such is not the great outdoorsmen that a Seminole is expected to be. The book discusses at great length the monetary success of the Seminoles (especially their big casino enterprise up in Hollywood) and portrays Sammy as a man at those crossroads: Trying to hold on to his Native roots while at the same time taking white culture and capitalizing on it.


He goes to hide in a place called Dismal Key out in the 10,000 Islands. For those unfamiliar, 10,000 Islands is an area mostly outside of Everglades National Park that is completely undeveloped wilderness and a popular spot for eco-tourism. We are not sure if there are, in fact, 10,000 islands, as it would take a really long time to count. But it is this popularity among the outdoorsy-types that leads the book’s heroine, Honey Santana, to lure an unsuspecting telemarketer named Boyd Shreave out to Florida for what he assumes to be one of those free “Come look at our land so you’ll but a condo”-type free vacations.



Honey, who we learn is not completely sane, lives in a trailer outside of Everglades City (yes, such a place really does exist) with her son, Fry. One night, after she has gone off her medication, she gets into an altercation with Shreave when he calls her after dinner trying to sell her land up in Gilchrist County, which, if you know anything about North Florida, more resembles a scene from “Deliverance” than “Miami Vice.”

Honey scams some frequent flier tickets from her ex-husband/baby daddy, a sort of rough and tumble Everglades lifer named Perry Skinner, finds Shreave’s personal information, and invites him and his mistress Eugenie out for what Honey describes as a week of fun and relaxation. Being a telemarketer, Shreave agrees to come assuming he will show up, hear the sales pitch, refuse it, and spend a week on the beautiful Florida coast.


Boyd Shreave is exactly the sort of man the name would imply, as Hiaasen once again gives his characters names which mark their personalities. Shreave is a slimy, spineless phone salesman who tries to think of himself as a real man in his suburban surrounding s, but lacks the integrity to do much of anything with his life. His mistress, who goes by the pseudonym Eugenie Fonda, would be a washed-up South Beach party girl if she lived here, but living in Texas is just a hot chick past her prime who is now slumming it with a telemarketer who can’t succeed at anything but selling real estate over the phone.



The trio - Honey, Shreave, and Eugenie - ineviatably get lost in the 10,000 Islands and stuck on Dismal Key with Sammy Tigertail, who by now has been forced by an adventure-seeking Florida State co-ed to take her hostage. The girl, Gillian, is enticed by the thought of being held hostage and ravaged by a hot native, and becomes agitated when Sammy shows no sexual interest in her. Their relationship makes for an interesting side story, as once Sammy finally starts to warm to Gillian and succumbs to her sexual advances, her enthusiasm for the situation wanes. Showing us once again that Hiaasen is a phenomenal observer of the human condition; once a 20-year-old girl realizes that the guy she likes likes her, she immediately loses interest.

Joining these folks on the island are a private investigator named Dealey, hired by Shreave’s perverted alomst-ex-wife to get a penetration shot of her husband and his mistress, Perry Skinner and his son who have come out looking for the boy’s mother, who they know will get lost, and Honey’s former boss Louis Piejack who has an unhealthy obsession with her and an even unhealthier fishy body odor. Piejack, it pays to mention, also recently had his hand forced into a Stone Crab trap by a group of Latino thugs from – where else – Hialeah, who were hired by Honey’s ex husband after Piejack molested her at work. So the stage is set for complete chaos, right?

Well, sort of. While Hiaasen does a masterful job of creating and developing his characters, and using the South Florida wilderness as a beautiful backdrop (if you’ve been to the Everglades you can almost feel yourself on Dismal Key) the plot almost seems like an excuse to get all these crazy people together n one place



The book is high on characterization, is extremely funny in many parts, has great conflict in every scene and uses the Everglades almost as a constant character to help the story along. But unfortunately, “Nature Girl” becomes like a baseball team full of great players who just can’t win the big game. The book keeps you reading only because you want to see what the characters do and how they interact, but does not have a long enough story to make you really care about what happens. Kind of like if you tried to condense “Lost” into 296 pages.


Hiaasen spends a great deal of time indirectly trying to get the readers to appreciate the beauty of the Everglades – and rightfully so – but it may have been better spent spinning a longer story. It almost feels like the book is too short,  like more needs to happen to make this a complete story. Once everyone is marooned on the island the main conflict is resolved faster than you want it to be. The characters’ interactions with each other, whether it is the washed-up 6-foot bombshell Eugenie giving her pearl tongue stud to Honey’s 12-year-old son for the “right girl,” or Shreave being humiliated by the young Indian, the time the characters spend together on the island seems too short.


So while anyone who enjoys Carl Hiaasen’s writing will most certainly enjoy “Nature Girl,” it is not really a satisfying read.  Hiaasen is almost undone by his own crafting of character and conflict, as the lack of story leaves us wanting more. And while the book was a New York Times bestseller, Hiaasen, as his personal integrity would dictate, is probably not looking to put out a sequel.

Related Categories: Hiaasen Reviews

About the Author: Matt Meltzer is a featured columnist at Miami Beach 411.

See more articles by Matt Meltzer.

See more articles by Matt Meltzer

Was This Post Helpful? Please Share It With Others!

You Deserve More Than an Ordinary Vacation.
Travel with Miami Beach 411 Today!
  • Over 10 years of excellent service guiding tours. Awarded a TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence.
  • Large fleet of new motor coaches, tour buses, and luxury vans. Technology you won't find anywhere.
  • Highly skilled, professional drivers and guides. From people who love what they do.
The Miami Beach 411 Travel Store is Open 24/7.
Search for Tours & Transportation

3 Comments on

"Nature Girl: Carl Hiaasen Goes Native"

Maria de los Angeles says:

Matt, are we living parallel lives? I just finished reading this book and started a new blog series inspired by it!  I agree, if you know the Glades, it’s a great satire, but also, you want it to go on.

Nevertheless, I love Hiaasen’s style. Only he can pull off 10K Islands “Lite” with enough adventure.  And I’ve been there, mosquitoes and all.  I once portaged a canoe down the Homestead Canal just so I could find (maybe find?) some Indian shell mounds.  Of course, I got eaten alive in the process.

Yeah, I know that’s Flamingo, but whatever. 

I once tried to camp all along the Wilderness Waterway (Everglades City to Flamingo) but I stopped half way.

It is really something else out there.  I could totally appreciate Hiaasen’s descriptions.  I think nothing funny of it though.  It’s really tough terrain and an even tougher experience.

Nature Girl is also a good side story to Adaptation (movie based on the The Orchid Thief).

Also, what of the fact that Gillian comes back after getting a refund on her college tuition, hiring a helicopter to fly over the islands to find Sammy?  I don’t think that this would constitute as “losing interest”.

Anyway, thanks for reviewing Nature Girl.  I thought it was a very fun read.

Posted on 07/28/2008 at 10:01 PM

Wendy Lampard says:

Very pleasurable reading a natural girl going native. Her story inspires me to change my lifestyle and be just like her. Thanks for sharing.

Posted on 11/19/2011 at 12:55 AM

Chris says:

Hey Maria, you sound like a cracker Glades Girl! I just got back from visiting Dismal Key today to do some “looking” found two old “square grouper” that a plane had dropped several years ago wrapped in plastic. You could still see some leaf and stalk material in one of the bales that was not in any condition for use.  The skeeters were present, as was the cactus and other plants that will put a beating on ya. Still lots of Calusa sign out there, and the remains of the two hermits that lived there for over a fifty year spread.  To round out your Glades history, you should visit the real Dismal Key. Chris   .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

Posted on 11/26/2011 at 9:31 PM

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.
Discuss the surrounding area in our hugely popular Miami forum.
Today's Miami Specials
Like what you see? Let's talk about
how we can help your vacation
--> Contact Us